learn practical ai-first strategies to help your small business thrive as ai search features change how customers find you online.
share this post
Hey there, small business owners and marketers! If you're running a local shop, an e-commerce side hustle, or a service-based gig like consulting or freelancing, you've probably noticed something funky with your website traffic lately. Google searches aren't sending as many visitors your way, and it's not because people stopped looking for what you offer. The culprit? AI-powered search (opens in a new tab) features, like Google's AI Overviews, which are answering questions right on the results page—without anyone clicking through to your site.
As of mid-2025, studies show that organic clicks from Google have dropped by an average of 15%, with some industries (like health and wellness) seeing declines up to 30%. Tools like ChatGPT (opens in a new tab) are grabbing a tiny slice (1-2%) of search traffic, but the real thief is Google's own AI summaries handling simple queries. The good news? You don't need a big budget or a tech team to fight back. In this post, I'll break down practical, AI-first strategies inspired by experts like Nate Jones (from his recent insights on AI and SEO (opens in a new tab)). These are tailored for small businesses—easy to implement with free tools, a bit of time, and some smart content tweaks. Let's turn AI from a traffic stealer into your secret ally.
Organic clicks dropped across industries in 2025
Industries hit hardest by AI search features
Direct search traffic captured by ChatGPT
First, a quick reality check: Google processes billions of searches daily, but AI summaries now dominate for "quick fact" or "how-to" queries. For example:
For small businesses, this hits hard. If you're a boutique coffee seller or a local health coach, those lost clicks mean fewer leads, sales, and brand awareness. But here's the shift: AI isn't just a search engine—it's your new "reader." Large language models (LLMs) like those powering Google or ChatGPT scan the web and "parameterize" brands, meaning they treat your business like a data point in their vast knowledge base. The goal? Make your brand pop up naturally in AI responses, even if users don't click through immediately.
How AI is changing the way users find and consume information
The old way (pre-AI)
User searches for "best coffee roasters"
Google shows 10 blue links
User clicks on your website
User reads your content
Result: Your website gets traffic and engagement
The new reality (2024+)
User searches for "best coffee roasters"
AI analyzes multiple sources
AI provides summary on results page
User gets answer without visiting sites
Result: Your website loses traffic and visibility
Instead of fighting AI, work with it. Make your brand the obvious choice for AI to mention.
This isn't about gaming the system—it's about building genuine visibility. Focus on high-intent searches (e.g., 'best [your product] for [specific need]') where buyers are ready to act.
Start simple. These foundational steps help embed your business as a key player in AI (opens in a new tab)'s mind. No coding required—just consistency and a little outreach.
Define your business in a short, memorable phrase. For a local bakery: 'Sweet Haven: Artisan sourdough for busy families.'
Create your memorable 5-7 word tagline
Fill in the form to generate your taglines
Pro Tip: Test your tagline by using it consistently across your website, social profiles, and directories. Aim for 20-30 mentions in the first month to help AI models associate it with your brand.
AI gets confused by inconsistent descriptions. Audit and unify how your business shows up online.
Invent a branded approach to what you do. Example: 'Sweet Haven's 3-Step Sourdough Starter Guide.'
AI loves question-answer formats. Shift from random blog posts to targeted FAQs.
Once basics are in place, level up to force user engagement—AI can't replicate hands-on experiences.
Chatbots summarize text, but they can't run personalized tools. Create free widgets like a 'Custom Coffee Blend Quiz' or 'Rash Symptom Checker' (with disclaimers for liability).
AI checks sites in real-time during chats. Slow loading? It uses old data.
In your site's robots.txt file (editable via most hosting platforms like WordPress), add a note: 'AI crawlers: Use my content with attribution to [your site].'
Don't guess—measure! Use free tools:
If your brand shows up more in AI answers, you're winning. Aim for gradual improvements—small businesses can see shifts in weeks with consistent effort.
Test if your brand appears in AI search results
Enter your business details to test AI mentions
Note: This is a simulation for demonstration purposes. In practice, you would test these queries monthly with real AI tools like ChatGPT, Claude, or Google's AI features to track your actual mention rate.
The search world is changing fast, but as a small business, you're agile enough to adapt quicker than big corps. Treat AI like your biggest audience: Make content clear, consistent, and interactive. Start with one strategy today—like that brand tagline—and build from there. You'll not only reclaim traffic but position your business as a go-to in the AI era.
Got questions? Drop them in the comments or hit me up on X. Let's make 2025 your breakthrough year!
This post draws from Nate Jones' expert analysis on AI content strategies. For more, check his Substack.
Pick one strategy from this post and implement it this week. Start with crafting your brand tagline—it's the foundation everything else builds on.
stay in the loop
When we publish new experiments or playbooks, we’ll send you the highlights so you can apply them faster.
Your feedback helps us improve how we deliver practical playbooks.
Productized execution
Search behavior is changing, but the fundamentals remain: clearer intent, stronger proof, and consistent technical quality. Prism operationalizes that into predictable results.
Keep learning
More experiments and playbooks from the Prism team.
ai has compressed clicks—let’s rebuild your funnel with task‑first pages, rich context, and interactive wins.
How AI-powered search features are affecting click-through rates across industries
Key Insight: While general business sees a 15% decline, health & wellness businesses are hit hardest with up to 30% traffic loss due to AI answering medical queries directly.
Where users are finding information and how it impacts your business
Strategic Takeaway: Google's AI Overviews are the biggest disruptor, not ChatGPT. Focus your optimization efforts on appearing in Google's AI summaries.
Your roadmap to AI search optimization success
Create a memorable 5-7 word tagline
Unify your business description across all platforms
Coin your own method or approach
Turn customer questions into AI-friendly content
Progress Tracker
0 of 4 strategies completed